TOP RATED 5 star DECKS & FENCES (630) 449-2662

MOON'S EXTERIOR SERVICE

COMPOSITE VS WOOD DECK: WHICH IS BETTER IN ILLINOIS?

GET MY FREE ESTIMATE NOW

Home › Blog

Composite, cedar or pressure-treated wood? A plain-English comparison for homeowners around Naperville.

The quick comparison

  • Pressure-treated wood: lowest cost up front; needs cleaning and staining every few years.
  • Cedar: costs more than pressure-treated; warmer look and natural resistance to rot and insects; still needs regular staining.
  • Composite: highest cost up front; no sanding or staining; an occasional wash keeps it clean.

Pressure-treated wood

Pressure-treated pine is the most common deck material in the Chicago suburbs. It is strong, widely available and the most budget-friendly choice. With a good stain every few years, it can last a long time.

The trade-off is upkeep. Untreated by stain, it turns gray, cracks and splinters. If you are fine with a staining schedule — or a maintenance plan — it is a great value.

Cedar

Cedar is the choice for homeowners who love real wood. It has a rich color, smells great, and resists rot and insects better than pine. It also takes stain beautifully. It costs more than pressure-treated wood and still needs regular cleaning and staining to keep its color.

Composite

Composite boards are made from a mix of wood fibers and plastic. The big advantage is maintenance: no sanding, no staining, no splinters. Wash it once or twice a year and it keeps its color.

The trade-offs are cost and feel. Composite costs more up front, and some people prefer the look and feel of real wood. Composite decks are usually built on a pressure-treated wood frame, so the frame still has to be built right.

Which holds up best in Illinois winters?

All three can last in our climate when the deck is built correctly. What usually ruins a deck here is not the board material, it is what is underneath: shallow footings that heave with frost, a ledger that lets water behind it, or joists that stay wet. Whatever you choose for the surface, make sure the structure is done right.

How to decide

  1. Budget now: pressure-treated is the lowest up-front cost.
  2. Budget over time: composite saves on staining and maintenance.
  3. Look: cedar for natural wood beauty, composite for a clean, even look.
  4. Upkeep: if you never want to stain, choose composite.
  5. Selling soon: a fresh, well-built deck in any material adds curb appeal.

We price every new deck as its own project, so we can quote the same deck in two materials and you can compare.

GET MY FREE ESTIMATE

Frequently asked questions

Is composite or wood better for a deck?

Composite costs more up front but needs almost no maintenance. Wood costs less but needs cleaning and staining every few years.

Cedar vs pressure-treated deck: which is better?

Pressure-treated is the budget choice. Cedar costs more, looks warmer and resists rot naturally. Both need regular staining.

How much does a new deck cost in Illinois?

It depends on size, height, material, stairs and railings. We price each new deck as its own project after a free visit.

Related: Deck Building · Service areas · All guides

THIS WEEK ONLY

NEW CUSTOMER SPECIAL

10% OFF YOUR FIRST SERVICE

Call or fill out the form below to claim your discount.

GET YOUR FREE ESTIMATE

We respond within the same day. No obligation, no pressure.

We respond the same day · (630) 449-2662

0/500

By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your project. We never sell or share your information. Privacy Policy